Skip to main content

Metal Roofing Vs. Shingle Roofing, Which Is Better?

Are you planning on building a home in the near future and are trying to decide what roof is best for you? Maybe your current roof is nearing the end of its life and you’re in the market for a new one. 

Regardless of why you need a roof, it’s important to look at all of the options available to you. In the past, most homeowners would have simply opted for the common, asphalt, shingle roof, but now, more are choosing metal roofing to protect their family, pets and possessions. 

So how do you know which residential roofing system is better? We’ve got the answer below. 

When it comes to determining metal roofing vs. shingle roofing, it boils down to a few factors, appearance, cost, and durability. 

So let’s get to the bottom (or top) of the question! 


Typically, in the past, shingles were the primary roof choice. There weren’t too many options to choose from but now metal roofs have become a popular choice for residential properties. 

Both metal and shingle roofing systems have made strides in the style category in recent years. 

Shingles can be made to look like slate, tile, wood and even have rounded scalloped edges for a more detailed finish. Metal roofs are no longer the corrugated metal that gives off an industrial look. Instead, they are sleek and modern with endless color options to give the home an updated look. 

Metal Roofing Vs. Shingle Roofing


A new roofing system is an expensive, but necessary investment. When deciding on a new roof both metal and shingle roof systems have various costs

A shingle roof is less expensive upfront, but over time with maintenance, shingle replacement, and lifespan of 20 years, the cost will add up. 

A metal roof is more expensive in the beginning but has a lifespan between 30-40 years and requires little to no maintenance or repair. Metal roofs are also energy efficient and you may even qualify for tax credits by installing one. 


As we said above a shingle roof has a lifespan of about 20 years and a metal roof can last around 40 years with proper maintenance.

Both are strong, stable systems but both have their weaknesses. 

Shingle roofs can lose shingles, grow mold, and moss, and can crack allowing water to penetrate beneath the top layer. 

Metal roofs can become damaged by hail and debris like falling limbs from trees. You can also damage a metal roof by walking on it improperly.

Durability matters. Both metal and shingle roofs are durable but it may come down to where you live and the type of weather you get in your area. 

Metal Roofing Vs. Shingle Roofing – What To Choose For Your Home

Metal roofing vs. shingle roofing – which is better? The answer is “it depends”. That may seem like a bad answer but it truly depends on where you live, what your budget is, the style you’re looking for and more. 

It is in your best interest to let a roofing company help you in the decision-making process because each home is different and they are the experts in their field. 

Here at Stephens Roofing we offer San Antonio metal roof installation and repair as well as shingle roofing installation and repair all throughout the southern Texas region. 

To learn more about the roofing services we provide, browse our website, and review our blog page featuring articles like, How to get your roof ready for spring

To further discuss your roofing needs, schedule your free estimate today.